The honest version of the answer to "what's the difference between tequila and mezcal" is this: they're both made from agave, but the rules around them are quite different, and in our experience the flavor gap between bottles is wider in mezcal.
Many drinkers have only tried the best-known mass-market brands of each. Get past those, and you're in genuinely different spirits. Here's the honest breakdown.
The legal definitions
Both are agave spirits, but the rules diverge fast. (Sources: Mexico's NOM-006-SCFI-2012 for tequila and NOM-070-SCFI-2016 for mezcal.)
| Rule | Tequila | Mezcal |
|---|---|---|
| Region | All of Jalisco plus named municipalities in Guanajuato, Michoacán, Nayarit and Tamaulipas | The states named in the mezcal denomination of origin, including Oaxaca |
| Agave species | One: Blue Weber (Agave tequilana) | Any species of the genus Agave, cultivated or wild, grown in the designated area |
| Categories | "100% agave," or plain "Tequila," which may include up to 49% sugars from other sources | Mezcal · Mezcal Artesanal · Mezcal Ancestral (by how it is cooked, milled, fermented and distilled) |
| Aging classes | Blanco · Joven/Oro · Reposado (at least 2 months in oak) · Añejo (at least 1 year) · Extra Añejo (at least 3 years) | Joven/Blanco · Madurado en Vidrio · Reposado (2-12 months in wood) · Añejo (over 12 months) · Abocado con · Destilado con |
| Alcohol by volume | 35-55% | 35-55% |
The agave-species rule alone is huge. Tequila is one plant; mezcal can be any Agave. That's why, in our experience, mezcal can range from light and citrusy (Espadín) to floral and tropical (Tobalá) to vegetal and savory (Madrecuixe). Tequila variation comes from the producer's choices, not the plant.
The three mezcal categories are defined by process. In the base "Mezcal" category, agave can be cooked in pit ovens, masonry ovens or autoclaves. "Artesanal" mezcal is cooked in pit or masonry ovens and distilled with direct fire in copper or clay pot stills. "Ancestral" mezcal is cooked in pit ovens and distilled in clay pots. "Pechuga" is made with a "destilado con" step, where ingredients such as turkey or chicken breast are added to the distillation.
What they taste like, honestly
Forget the "tequila is sharp, mezcal is smoky" shorthand. It's lazy.
Good tequila tastes like cooked agave — sweet, vegetal, peppery, with a long mineral finish if it's well-made. Tequila Ocho and Cascahuín are two blancos we carry and like to sip neat.
Good mezcal tastes like its agave variety, the village it came from, the wood used to roast it. In our experience smoke is one note among many. The texture is often viscous, the finish long and evolving. Read more in our single-village mezcal guide.
The real difference at the high end isn't the flavor profile. It's the level of variation. Two well-made tequilas from different distillers will taste different, but recognizably tequila. Two well-made mezcals from different villages and different agave species can taste like different spirits entirely.
Additives in tequila
Under NOM-006, blanco tequila is defined as having no added flavoring (abocante), but reposado, añejo and extra añejo may be "abocado," meaning flavoring is allowed. Whether a tequila uses additives is a producer's choice, so it's worth asking before you buy.
Tequilas we carry and like for sipping include Tequila Ocho Plata ($60), Cascahuín Tequila Blanco ($55) and G4 Blanco ($40).
What to look for in mezcal
The mezcal we find most interesting is single-village and single-producer, from projects like Cinco Sentidos, which names the mezcalero, the village and the agave species for every bottle. That kind of labeling tells you what you're buying. The mezcals in our online shop today run from $40 to $165.
Which one should you drink?
Wrong question. The right answer is "both, depending on what you're doing."
For cocktails: blanco tequila is the workhorse. A good blanco like Tequila Ocho Plata or Cascahuín Tahona Blanco makes margaritas and palomas better, in our opinion. A good mezcal Espadín can also work, though smoke can get lost behind citrus.
For sipping neat: good blanco tequila or good single-village mezcal. The choice is mood: tequila is brighter, faster-finishing, more linear. Mezcal is slower, more textured, more demanding of attention. Reposado and añejo tequilas (oak-aged) are easier introductions to the category for whiskey drinkers.
For something rare: mezcal made from agave species like Tobalá, Madrecuixe and Arroqueño has no equivalent in tequila, whose rules allow only blue Weber agave.
Buying tequila and mezcal in Chicago
Off Premise stocks both. Current categories on our shelf:
- Tequila — blanco, reposado, añejo and extra añejo
- Mezcal Espadín — including Cinco Sentidos bottlings
- Mezcal from other agaves — including Tobalá, Madrecuixe, Mexicano and Arroqueño
- Raicilla — agave-adjacent, with its own designation
If you walk in unsure, tell us what you currently drink and we'll point you to a bottle. Free tastings run every Friday, 5-8pm.
If you're new to good agave: start with Tequila Ocho Plata ($60) for tequila or Cinco Sentidos Espadín con Picudo ($120) for mezcal. Either bottle is sippable straight or in a simple cocktail (margarita, paloma, mezcal Negroni).
What about sotol and raicilla?
Sotol is made from Dasylirion, a different plant from agave. Raicilla has its own Mexican designation, separate from tequila and mezcal; we carry one raicilla, La Venenosa ($110).
Both are agave-adjacent and worth trying once you've explored mezcal.
Come visit
Off Premise · 1128 W Armitage Ave, Lincoln Park.
Hours: Sunday through Thursday, noon to 7pm · Friday and Saturday, noon to 9pm.
Free Friday tastings every week, 5–8pm.
Browse the agave selection →More agave reading
→ Single-village mezcal in Chicago: a buyer's guide
→ The best mezcal under $60 in Chicago